High Court of Kerala
Case Law Search
A.K.NARAYANAN, CHIEF FOOD INSPECTOR v. REJI C.GEORGE, DISTRICT FOOD INSPECTOR - WA No. 815 of 2006(B)  RD-KL 1966 (25 January 2007)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAMWA No. 815 of 2006(B)
1. A.K.NARAYANAN, CHIEF FOOD INSPECTOR,
1. REJI C.GEORGE, DISTRICT FOOD INSPECTOR,
2. THE DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES,
3. THE STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY THE
For Petitioner :SRI.K.RAMAKUMAR
For Respondent :SRI.T.A.SHAJI
The Hon'ble MR. Justice K.A.ABDUL GAFOOR The Hon'ble MR. Justice K.R.UDAYABHANU
O R D E RK.A.ABDUL GAFOOR &
K.R. UDAYABHANU, JJ.
W.A.NOS.815 & 1312 OF 2006
DATED THIS THE 25th DAY OF JANUARY 2007
Abdul Gafoor,J.The Government as well as the second respondent in the writ petition are aggrieved by the judgment in W.P.(C) 27679/2005 whereby Ext.P7 has been quashed directing the Government to consider the matter again. The fact position of the case is as follows:
2. The writ petitioner Regi.C.George was a Food Inspector.
He was promoted to the post of Chief Food Inspector and he
occupying the promotion post since 27-5-2000, though there is
allegation that he was occupying that post
on officiation even
earlier. While posting him as Chief Food Inspector, his junior
as District Food Inspector, the category to be filled
up by transfer of the incumbents working in the category of the
Chief Food Inspector. The appointment by transfer is regulated
28(b) of the Kerala State & Subordinate Service Rules.
Necessarily the incumbent to be posted by transfer
suitable senior most incumbents in the category of Chief Food
Inspector. Therefore, the Government
found it erroneous to
retain Regi.C.George as Chief Food Inspector and his junior as
District Food Inspector
and accordingly rectified that error by
posting Regi.C.George as District Food Inspector. According to
him, he had already relinquished the posting as District Food
Inspector. But this was disputed by the Government
there was no relinquishment letter in advance before such
posting. Anyhow he approached
this Court aggrieved by his
posting as District Food Inspector. This Court directed
of the matter by the Government and the
Government passed Ext.P5. The relinquishment was rejected.
This was again challenged before this Court by filing a writ
petition which resulted in
Ext.P6 judgment wherein fresh
consideration was directed. In Ext.P6 judgment it was directed
"In such circumstances, the writ petition is W.A.NOS.815&1312/2006 -3- disposed of with a direction to the first respondent to consider and pass orders on Exts.P13 and P14 in accordance with law. No doubt learned counsel for the petitioner referred to the provisions of Rule 38 of the K.S.& S.S.R., which provides that a relinquishment can be rejected only on the reasons of public interest. If the relinquishment given by the petitioner is accepted, then there will be a further direction that the petitioner shall be posted back as Chief Food Inspector, Mobile Vigilance Squad, Kozhikode and the second respondent shall be placed back as District Food Inspector, Wayanad. A decision in this regard shall be taken within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment." In Ext.P7 again the relinquishment has been rejected in the following lines: "As per Rule 38 of the K.S.& S.S.R,.a
relinquishment can be accepted only if it is not opposed to public interest. Order number referred to as fourth paper above W.A.NOS.815&1312/2006 -4- was issued to rectify the irregularities in order No.read as 1st paper above. It is done on public interest. Sri.Regi.C.George had accepted the grade promotion in the post of Food Inspector on condition that he will not relinquish promotion in the normal line as per the condition for giving grade promotion. Hence the relinquishment request of Sri. Regi.C.George is rejected and the status quo as ordered in Order No.EG1-24854/05/DHS dated 20-05- 2005 is maintained." This was challenged in W.P.(C)No.27679/2005 by Regi.C.George again contending that the rejection of the relinquishment is not in public interest as required in Rule 38 of the General Rules in K.S.& S.S.R., but because of the fact that he had obtained grade promotion while working as Food Inspector with the condition that he will not relinquish regular promotions. According to him, further promotion was to the post of Chief Food Inspector which he accepted. The post of District Food Inspector is yet another category, though on the same scale of pay to be filled by appointment on transfer from Chief Food Inspector. Therefore, W.A.NOS.815&1312/2006 -5- that cannot be a reason to reject the relinquishment.
3. The portion extracted in Ext.P7 impugned order as
above does not spell out the germane consideration
of Rule 38 of the General Rules as to whether it was in public
interest. Consideration of public
interest in a posting like this
shall reflect the following aspects generally.
a) whether experience in working as Chief Food Inspector is essential for being posted as District Food Inspector for efficient and effective administration of the department and whether that will have to be the prime most consideration of public interest.?
b) Continuance of an incumbent in the post for long as Chief Food Inspector will be conducive to public interest.
c)Whether the relinquishment of the post of District Food Inspector by one incumbent resulting in another being retained as District Food Inspector is conducive to public interest.
4. Other aspects also may arise in public interest. Nothing of that sort is reflected in Ext.P7. In such circumstances, it is only appropriate that the Government shall consider all the above aspects and any further aspect germane to public interest W.A.NOS.815&1312/2006 -6- and pass fresh orders within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. Pending consideration by the Government, status quo as on today with respect to the parties in the Writ appeal shall be maintained. The posting of incumbents shall also be based on the norms. The writ appeal is disposed of accordingly. Sd/- K.A.ABDUL GAFOOR
Double Click on any word for its dictionary meaning or to get reference material on it.